We are happy to take your claim reports during our agency’s business hours. If you would prefer to report your claim directly to the insurance carrier and/or are reporting a loss outside of our business hours, please use the carrier’s phone number listed below or report the claim at the carrier’s website.
Please note that we will be notified about any claims that you report directly to the insurance carrier and we will be happy to answer any questions you may have about a claim that you have reported to us or to the carrier.
Our Providers
- Auto-Owners Insurance
- GEICO
- Cincinnati Insurance
- Progressive
- Westfield Insurance
- Foremost Insurance
- Grange Insurance
- Goodville Mutual
- Safeco Insurance
Carrier Phone Numbers
The following numbers are available to call to pay directly by phone. Please be aware that other fees may apply when paying by phone.
| Carrier | Phone |
|---|---|
| Auto Owners Insurance Company | 888-252-4626 |
| GEICO | 1-866-509-9444 |
| Cincinnati Insurance Companies | 877-242-2544 |
| Foremost Insurance Company | 800-527-3907 |
| Goodville Insurance Company | 877-445-5780 |
| Grange Insurance Company | Glass 800-951-9734 · Non-Glass 800-445-3030 |
| Mennonite Mutual Insurance Company | 800-678-6885 |
| Ohio Fair Plan | 1-800-282-1772 |
| Progressive | 1-877-278-1615 |
| Safeco Insurance Company | 800-332-3226 |
| Westfield Insurance Company | 800-243-0210 |
