We strongly suggest you pay bills sent to you by the insurance company directly to the insurance carrier. There are many ways to do that such as electronic funds transfer, mailing a check directly to the carrier, or making a credit card payment at the carrier’s website. Be sure that your payment is sent in plenty of time to ensure that your coverage is not cancelled due to a late payment receipt at the carrier.
If the insurance carrier you choose does not bill you directly, the agency will bill you and upon receipt of your payment, forward your payment to the carrier. Please pay those bills early, too to ensure that your coverage stays in force.
Our Providers
- Auto-Owners Insurance
- GEICO
- Cincinnati Insurance
- Progressive
- Westfield Insurance
- Foremost Insurance
- Grange Insurance
- Goodville Mutual
- Safeco Insurance
Pay by Phone
The following numbers are available to call to pay directly by phone. Please be aware that other fees may apply when paying by phone.
| Carrier | Phone |
|---|---|
| Auto Owners Insurance Company | 1-800-288-8740 |
| Cincinnati Insurance Companies | 1-800-364-3400 |
| Foremost Insurance Company | 1-800-532-4221 |
| Goodville Insurance Company | 1-800-854-4695 |
| Grange Insurance Company | 1-800-425-1100 |
| Mennonite Mutual Insurance Company | 1-800-678-6885 |
| Ohio Fair Plan | 1-800-282-1772 |
| Progressive | 1-877-278-1615 |
| Safeco Insurance Company | 1-800-332-3226 |
| Westfield Insurance Company | 1-800-766-9133 |
