Family owned & independent since 1900
Business InsuranceFarm & Crop InsuranceOhio School District InsurancePersonal Auto InsuranceHomeowners InsurancePublic Entity & Municipal InsuranceRenters InsuranceUmbrella InsuranceBoat, RV & Motorcycle InsuranceLife Insurance
Wintersville · (740) 264-2003Bergholz · (740) 768-2121Carrollton · (330) 627-7717
The McBane family in front of the original McBane Insurance office in Bergholz, Ohio

Our team

16 professionals. One family name.

Our team of dedicated insurance professionals is our most valuable asset. We invest in the continuing education of our staff, and each team member is skilled in offering solutions to protect your lifestyle and passions.

01 · 2 people

Leadership

Fourth-generation owners of the agency James McBane founded in 1900.

Dave McBane

Dave McBane

President

Dan McBane

Dan McBane

Vice President · Wintersville

02 · 3 people

Producers

Your agents: they shop the market and build your coverage.

Reece Kelly

Reece Kelly

Producer

Alec McBane

Alec McBane

Producer

Christopher Nehrbas

Christopher Nehrbas

Producer

03 · 3 people

Commercial Lines

Business, farm, school, and public-entity accounts.

Theresa Marteney

Theresa Marteney

Commercial Lines Account Manager

Shela Carson

Shela Carson

Commercial Lines Account Manager

Jenna Allender

Jenna Allender

Personal & Commercial Lines Account Manager

04 · 5 people

Personal Lines

Auto, home, renters, umbrella, and recreational policies.

Malissa Long

Malissa Long

Personal Lines Account Manager

Randi Barrett

Randi Barrett

Personal Lines Account Manager

Deseree Burdette

Deseree Burdette

Personal Lines Account Manager

Sonya Bailey

Sonya Bailey

Personal Lines Account Manager

Matt Lemmon

Matt Lemmon

Personal Lines Account Manager

05 · 3 people

Operations & Quality

Keeping every policy accurate, every bill right, and every office running.

Meghan Crow

Meghan Crow

Office & Quality Manager

Christy Kemmer

Christy Kemmer

Accounting and Personal Lines Quality Manager

Andrea Butream

Andrea Butream

Office Administrator

Get a quote

Let’s find the right coverage together.

One conversation, several insurance companies compared, and a local agent who picks up the phone when you have a claim.