Family owned & independent since 1900
Business InsuranceFarm & Crop InsuranceOhio School District InsurancePersonal Auto InsuranceHomeowners InsurancePublic Entity & Municipal InsuranceRenters InsuranceUmbrella InsuranceBoat, RV & Motorcycle InsuranceLife Insurance
Wintersville · (740) 264-2003Bergholz · (740) 768-2121Carrollton · (330) 627-7717
Living room in a bright apartment

Personal insurance

Renters Insurance

Covers your belongings, your liability, and a place to stay if a fire or other covered loss forces you out of your apartment or rental home.

Whether you rent an apartment in Steubenville, a house in Carrollton, or you’re a student at Franciscan University, your landlord’s insurance doesn’t cover your belongings or your liability. Renters insurance does — usually for less than the cost of a dinner out each month.

What renters insurance covers

  • Your belongings — furniture, clothing, electronics, and other personal property, whether they’re damaged at home or stolen from your car
  • Personal liability — if a guest is injured in your home or you accidentally damage someone else’s property
  • Additional living expenses — hotel, meals, and other costs if a covered loss forces you to move out while repairs are made
  • Medical payments to others — minor injuries to guests, regardless of fault

Replacement cost vs. actual cash value

This is the most important choice on a renters policy. Actual cash value pays what your used belongings are worth today, after depreciation. Replacement cost pays what it costs to buy new. The difference in premium is usually small and the difference in a claim can be large. We’ll show you both.

Coverage to ask about

  • Jewelry, firearms, collectibles, and other valuables that have lower limits on a standard policy
  • Water backup from a sewer or drain
  • Flood coverage if you live in a flood-prone area
  • Higher liability limits, especially if you have a dog

Local help when you need it

When something goes wrong, you can call or stop in at our Wintersville, Bergholz, or Carrollton office and talk with someone who knows you. We’ll help with the claim, too.

Couple relaxing on the floor of their home
Steubenville, Ohio skyline and the Ohio River

In their words

Clients who count on us.

The last 5 years have been a bit hectic for the Scurti’s. A new car, a new home, and even a new business. McBane has been there every step of the way. The agency’s attention to detail and willingness to take questions at any time via phone or email has brought us so much peace of mind as we’ve completed these important investments. After many years of efficient, cost-effective services, I’m proud to say that the McBane team has become more than advisors; they are trusted friends who will be alongside us in the future.
Evan and Carol Scurti
We’ve always found McBane Insurance to be there when you need them. They have gone out of their way to earn our business and have even contacted us to tell us about less-expensive insurance options with better coverage. We highly recommend Reece Kelly and McBane Insurance.
Mike and Gwen Sullivan
McBane is a company that is built on honesty and integrity. We have found that each employee that we work with has the same intangibles and we are always treated with the utmost respect. There is never a question that we haven’t had answered and we have always been given an explanation. The City of Heath is fortunate to have them as a working partner.
Jay MorrowCity Auditor, City of Heath
The McBane Insurance agency has provided us with knowledgeable, efficient, personable, and prompt service! This is the type of service that has the client first in mind! Our liability, fleet, and cyber insurance that McBane has provided has increased our coverage at a lower cost. I highly recommend McBane for all of your insurance needs.
Melissa BakerTreasurer, United Local School District
01 / 04

FAQ

Renters questions, answered.

Doesn't my landlord's insurance cover my things?

No. Your landlord's policy covers the building. Your furniture, clothes, electronics, and other belongings — and your own liability — are only covered by a renters policy.

What does renters insurance cover?

A renters policy typically covers your personal property against losses like fire, smoke, theft, and water damage from a burst pipe; personal liability if someone is hurt or you damage someone else's property; and additional living expenses if a covered loss makes your rental unlivable.

Does renters insurance cover flooding?

Standard renters policies do not cover flood from rising water. If you live near the Ohio River or another flood-prone area, ask us about separate flood coverage for your belongings.

Can I bundle renters insurance with my auto policy?

Usually, yes. Many carriers offer a multi-policy discount when you insure your car and your rental with them. We'll compare bundled and separate options.

Every office, every line

Renters Insurance near you.

WestfieldCincinnati InsuranceAuto-Owners InsuranceGrange InsuranceProgressiveForemost Insurance GroupSafeco InsuranceAnthemMedical MutualGoodville Mutual

Get a quote

Let’s find the right coverage together.

One conversation, several insurance companies compared, and a local agent who picks up the phone when you have a claim.