Family owned & independent since 1900
Business InsuranceFarm & Crop InsuranceOhio School District InsurancePersonal Auto InsuranceHomeowners InsurancePublic Entity & Municipal InsuranceRenters InsuranceUmbrella InsuranceBoat, RV & Motorcycle InsuranceLife Insurance
Wintersville · (740) 264-2003Bergholz · (740) 768-2121Carrollton · (330) 627-7717
Red umbrella in the rain

Personal insurance

Personal Umbrella Insurance

An extra layer of liability protection that sits above your auto and homeowners policies when a serious claim exceeds their limits.

Your auto and homeowners policies each carry a liability limit. When a serious accident or injury claim goes past that limit, you’re personally on the hook for the rest — and that can mean your savings, your home, or your future wages. A personal umbrella policy adds a layer of liability protection above those policies so one bad day doesn’t undo what you’ve built.

Who should consider an umbrella

An umbrella makes sense for more people than you might think. We most often recommend one if you:

  • Own a home, land, or other assets you want to protect
  • Have a teenage or newly licensed driver in the household
  • Own a swimming pool, trampoline, or dog
  • Own rental property
  • Own a boat, ATV, UTV, or other recreational vehicles
  • Coach youth sports, volunteer, or serve on a nonprofit board
  • Have a high income or expect your earnings to grow

What an umbrella policy covers

  • Excess liability above your auto, homeowners, and watercraft policies
  • Bodily injury and property damage you’re legally responsible for
  • Legal defense costs, which are often paid in addition to the limit
  • Personal injury claims such as libel, slander, and false arrest on many policies

Every carrier’s umbrella form is a little different. As an independent agency, we compare several and explain in plain language what each one does and doesn’t cover.

Why buy your umbrella through McBane

Umbrella policies only work if the policies underneath them are set up correctly. Because we handle your auto, home, and recreational coverage too, we line up the limits so there are no gaps. We’ve been doing that for families across the Ohio Valley since 1900, from our offices in Wintersville, Bergholz, and Carrollton.

Mother and children playing in the park in autumn
Historic two-story home with a front porch

In their words

Clients who count on us.

The last 5 years have been a bit hectic for the Scurti’s. A new car, a new home, and even a new business. McBane has been there every step of the way. The agency’s attention to detail and willingness to take questions at any time via phone or email has brought us so much peace of mind as we’ve completed these important investments. After many years of efficient, cost-effective services, I’m proud to say that the McBane team has become more than advisors; they are trusted friends who will be alongside us in the future.
Evan and Carol Scurti
We’ve always found McBane Insurance to be there when you need them. They have gone out of their way to earn our business and have even contacted us to tell us about less-expensive insurance options with better coverage. We highly recommend Reece Kelly and McBane Insurance.
Mike and Gwen Sullivan
McBane is a company that is built on honesty and integrity. We have found that each employee that we work with has the same intangibles and we are always treated with the utmost respect. There is never a question that we haven’t had answered and we have always been given an explanation. The City of Heath is fortunate to have them as a working partner.
Jay MorrowCity Auditor, City of Heath
The McBane Insurance agency has provided us with knowledgeable, efficient, personable, and prompt service! This is the type of service that has the client first in mind! Our liability, fleet, and cyber insurance that McBane has provided has increased our coverage at a lower cost. I highly recommend McBane for all of your insurance needs.
Melissa BakerTreasurer, United Local School District
01 / 04

FAQ

Umbrella questions, answered.

What does an umbrella policy cover?

A personal umbrella pays liability claims after your auto, homeowners, or watercraft liability limits are used up — for example, a serious at-fault accident or an injury on your property. Many umbrellas also cover claims your other policies don't, such as libel or slander. Exact coverage depends on the carrier, and we'll walk you through the differences.

How much umbrella coverage do I need?

Umbrellas are usually sold in $1 million increments. A good starting point is enough coverage to protect what you own and what you'll earn — your home, savings, and future income. We'll help you size it based on your situation.

Do I need to change my auto or home policy to get an umbrella?

Usually yes, a little. Umbrella carriers require minimum liability limits on the policies underneath. We check your current limits and adjust them so there's no gap between where your auto or home coverage stops and your umbrella starts.

Is umbrella insurance expensive?

It's often one of the least expensive ways to add a large amount of protection. Price depends on things like the number of drivers and vehicles, properties you own, and watercraft. We'll quote it with multiple carriers.

Every office, every line

Umbrella Insurance near you.

WestfieldCincinnati InsuranceAuto-Owners InsuranceGrange InsuranceProgressiveForemost Insurance GroupSafeco InsuranceAnthemMedical MutualGoodville Mutual

Get a quote

Let’s find the right coverage together.

One conversation, several insurance companies compared, and a local agent who picks up the phone when you have a claim.